cd longevity

From: Antonio Carlini <arcarlini_at_iee.org>
Date: Fri May 7 17:17:11 2004

> Vinyl LP's, carefully maintained, have a lifetime estimated
> to be 100 years or more; when played on high-quality
> turntables, wear isn't really an issue.

Assuming you don't mind the $10,000 outlay, you can get a
turntable that uses an optical (laser) pickup. Then wear
*really* isn't an issue. Data density and media fragility
might be though.

> Unfortunately, no mention was made of CDs using a gold layer
> which is supposed to greatly increase their durability.
> Didn't Kodak discontinue their manufacture of such gold CDs a
> while back due to a lack of demand for them?

I'm not sure you can rely on "Brand X" being invariant
over any substantial period of time, i.e. the media
you tested 6 months ago may well be manufactured
slightly differently (or completely differently) now.
Bulk buying may not help either - I expect that the
stuff degrades on the shelf even before it is used.

I'm not sure that worrying about the next 50 years
is appropriate anyway. We're losing a good deal of
stuff right now because it's not being archived
in the first place. Once it's digital (in some
reasonable form: HD, CD, DVD, etc.) then replicating
losslessly (assuming you have some sort of checksumming
and multiple copies for when one set of media goes
bad) is at least feasible.

Antonio
 
-- 
---------------
Antonio Carlini             arcarlini_at_iee.org
Received on Fri May 07 2004 - 17:17:11 BST

This archive was generated by hypermail 2.3.0 : Fri Oct 10 2014 - 23:37:09 BST